There is a very large question that remains unanswered concerning this mirror. The Mirror of Erised looms large in the Harry Potter canon, even if its appearances in the books are scant.
In the movie adaptation, Harry only sees his parents. How can the Mirror know something that Harry himself does not? "I believe this was written by J.K. Rowling herself.New comments cannot be posted and votes cannot be castWelcome to r/HarryPotter, the place where fans from around the world can meet and discuss everything in the Harry Potter universe! This duel was a big turning point for Dumbledore and could probably be compared to Snape worst memory.
But the books—the seven original Harry Potter books—are special. Clearly it has some ability to read minds, it must in order to know what one's "heart's desire" is. One thing he may have seen was a different outcome in the duel which killed Arianna. It might have stayed in the chamber or returned to its classroom. Dumbledore says that he was rather proud of the enchantment that placed the Stone within the mirror. Click here to watch the sermon. At least some content in this article is derived from information featured in For gameplay-specific information, please see the relevant article on Indeed, it became grimly apparent over the years that the mirror could bring more harm than good; many wasted their lives before the mirror, losing track of reality as they were deluded by what they saw and unable or unwilling to accept it as mere fantasy. Please make sure you have typed your email address correctly. So he may have seen Arianna survive and Grindelwald stunned which would have changed everything.In my head canon I'd like to think he sees his young self together with a young Gellert, who hugs him and cares for him. Similarly, neither Harry nor Quirrell has seen the Stone. Which, by changing the spacing and punctuation, reveals: It is no coincidence that ‘Erised’ backwards spells ‘Desire,” the basis of the magical mirror’s enchantment.
The life of my Lolo and my family in the Philippines is a deep reminder that people live full lives there and places like it, across the globe.Naz Riahi reflects on how the violent death of her father when she was a young girl impacted the rest of her lifeI wish I could talk to my mom about the irony that, forty years later, shelves are being ransacked and we are standing in lines to buy bread.You have flagged this story. In the last book Harry think he knew what Dumbledore saw in the mirror. It is possible that Harry has been exposed to so much in the way of apparently nonsensical text, with the spell incantations and other writings being often almost nonsense words, that he no longer automatically tries to decipher writings that he does not immediately understand. Confirmation link sent to your email to add you to notification list for author Abby Johnston
Be sorted, earn house points, take classes with our fine Hogwarts staff, debate which actor portrayed Dumbledore the best, and finally get some closure for your Post-Potter Depression.Press J to jump to the feed. Given that the mirror can read minds to some limited extent, there are two possible explanations for the mirror being able to show Harry his parents. The Gospel According to Harry Potter: The Mirror of Erised. Fandom may earn an affiliate commission on sales made from links on this page.Fandom may earn an affiliate commission on sales made from links on this page. By using our Services or clicking I agree, you agree to our use of cookies. I like to believe that he would see something close to the Dumbledore family portrait, because that was taken when he was the happiest he would ever be.I think he sees himself just holding socks, because of a silly reason (like he's not wearing any at that moment, or couldn't find them). We know that the Mirror's depiction is accurate because, in later books, and later in this book, Harry will find artifacts that show his parents and will not discover that the Mirror got it wrong. If you have any questions, please email We are also offering a 20% tuition break for any student who has lost work due to the Covid-19 outbreak. In this latter case, the Mirror could present the mental image each had of the Stone; it is enough to show something that the individual recognizes as "the Philosopher's Stone," even if it does not match the reality of what the Stone looks like. This edition is for us to know what did they see if they looked at the Mirror of Erised. Haven't set your password? And slowly, Harry looked into the faces of the other people in the mirror, and saw other pairs of green eyes like his, other noses like his, even a little old man who looked as though he had Harry's knobbly knees -- Harry was looking at his family, for the first time in his life. Mirror Of Erised Quotes (4 quotes). We first see the mirror in Harry Potter and the Sorcerer’s Stone, when our eleven-year-old protagonist finds it in an abandoned classroom. It is also possible that the enchantment is working on a slightly different level than the mirror. The movies are fine, and the Broadway and Fantastic Beasts spinoffs are acceptable. As an introduction to Dumbledore it’s pretty telling: an evasive answer, yes, but one given kindly and with his classic, whimsical sense of humour that stops Harry asking any more questions. Additionally, it is possible that the mirror could have seen what Harry's parents look like through his scar, which we find out in the final book is an indicator of the soul shard of